City Supply was the perfect place for a tourist like myself looking for unique gifts and knick knacks alike. They gave shirts, mugs, sauces, spices, and even fancy drink mixers like homemade simple syrups! Such a cozy little place right in the town square! Highly recommend this place.

Good place. Comfortable

City Supply has some of the coolest gift ideas. I keep buying to add to camping gear, coffee bar and my reading material. Plus I gift it to others for their collection. Some things are expensive while others are comparative in prices.

Really friendly staff and super fun and up beat environment from the store! They have a lot of local items for sale that represent the area which is pretty cool, and they sell dog biscuits that my dog absolutely loves!

It was my first time in the shop it looked really interesting for me outside so I thought I’ll check it out. I started walking around the store and I felt this guy following me and it was one of the Employees. I didn’t think much of it I thought he was going to come and ask me if I needed anything but he didn’t.I just kept on browsing then I noticed he was following me throughout the store. He made me feel like he was following me because he thought I was going to steal some thing and at some point I just told my kids let’s go they are following us like we’re going to steal something here. Made me feel very uncomfortable and not welcoming at all.

Cool spot for gifts. Gift bundles for mom, candles, BBQ rubs and sauces, sort of a random collection of items that make great gifts for friends and family.

Great selection with unique and harder to find brands.

Really cool selection of southern kitchen kitsch and some pet gifts too. Please wear your masks over your nose AND mouth when you shop!

A little overpriced on certain items but a fun shop to shop at they have a wide variety of things here

Such a great store! So many great things you can spend hours in there! Love that they support and carry a many local items. The staff couldn’t be more helpful. One employee Harrison who is new to the City Supply team went above and beyond today to help me get the perfect father’s day gifts last minute. Even after being there all day he was so helpful and stayed 30 minutes after they closed to help me. Highly recommend.

Great place to shop with lots of fun surprises. Fun place to find unique gifts for anyone.

Great business. I had an issue with a phone order so I called the store and spoke with Chase. He immediately had the item shipped overnight to me. Amazing customer service and products! I am no longer a local to Fayetteville but will continue to shop here and have items shipped to Louisiana. I highly recommend City Supply here whether you are near or far!

Aesthetically pleasing store with a masculine leaning atmosphere. Some unique products but definitely a narrow product line. Lots of mugs and tee shirts and such. Cute but not a place I would visit more than once or twice a year.

Classic Americana gifts and even a few witty surprises inside. Staff is always friendly and the products they sell are always quality.

I’ve already been here 3 times since they opened and LOVE it. They have a great selection of classic pieces-I love the neutrals and simplicity of their store. Great aesthetic and priced very well, especially compared to similar shops in the Fay area.

Neat stuff in there

I absolutely ove City Supply! A wonderful selection of unique products to choose from. I go in looking for gifts and end up wanting to buy everything for myself! The staff is always pleasant and welcoming!

Great store & selection. They have great customer service values!

Local flavor

Such a cute place. Enjoyed going through it.